Amazon's Black Friday Ad Surcharge Hit 250%, FTC Says. Bid Like It.

Amazon's Black Friday Ad Surcharge Hit 250%, FTC Says. Bid Like It.
Unsealed filings put alleged peak-day Amazon surcharges at up to 250%. The FTC's release lists the new figures.

The FTC and 22 states unsealed new details on November 5 from their lawsuit over Amazon's ad auction. They allege hidden "soft reserve" surcharges raised advertiser prices up to 50% above auction results on normal days and up to 250% on Prime Day and Black Friday. That means Q4 Sponsored Products CPC benchmarks from 2021 to 2023 are probably inflated. Rebase them before setting this year's Black Friday bids.

Most coverage will treat this as a courtroom story. I'd treat it as a bidding story, because the unsealed numbers describe how the auction you're about to bid into for Cyber Week has apparently behaved for years. And that has practical consequences for how you set bids in the next three weeks.

What the unredacted complaint actually adds

The original suit was filed in late August in the Western District of Washington, alleging Amazon secretly layered surcharges on top of its second-price auction. A lot of the specifics were blacked out. The FTC's November 5 release fills in some of them:

  • 2021 holiday season: average cost per click allegedly rose 20%, with some advertisers seeing increases above 200%.
  • 2022 holiday season: Amazon allegedly raised the surcharges and brought in an extra $87 million in worldwide revenue.
  • Prime Day 2023: a large food and beverage advertiser allegedly saw price increases above 100%, which Amazon internally described as "destroying campaign performance."
  • 2023 revenue gap: the head of Amazon Ads allegedly wrote that he wanted to "pull out all of the stops (without doing unnatural acts) to close our gaps to plan," adding that "ideally at least $40MM" from reserves would help.

The part that stings, if you were managing Amazon budgets in those years, is the account manager reply. Per the FTC, an advertiser asked whether something had changed with the second-price auction "either by design or mistake." The answer they got was that there was "not a bug, or a change in auction style," and that the marketplace was "even more crowded than any year previous."

So the official explanation was competition. The complaint's explanation is a revenue target.

As Search Engine Journal's Brooke Osmundson points out, the release doesn't say whether the practices continued past 2023 or which ad formats the newest numbers cover. Earlier filings named Sponsored Products, Sponsored Brands and Display. All of this is still an allegation, and Amazon denies it.

Amazon's defense, read as a bidding instruction

Amazon's response to the original suit leans hard on one line: "In no scenario does an advertiser pay more than their bid." It explains that a soft reserve is a real-time estimate of a placement's market value. If your winning bid clears it, you pay the soft reserve. If your bid clears the hard reserve but not the soft one, you still win the placement and pay your own bid.

Read that second case slowly. When the soft reserve sits above your bid, there's no second-price discount at all. You pay exactly what you typed in. Mechanically, for that click, it's a first-price auction.

And according to the complaint's figures, that case seems to have become the norm. Relevant Audience's breakdown of the filing reports the share of clicks charged at the advertiser's own bid went from about 4% in late 2020 to roughly 70% in 2022 and 79.1% in 2024. Amazon disputes the framing, but notice that its own defense and the FTC's number point at the same practical conclusion.

If you pay your bid four times out of five, your bid is your price.

An analogy that helped me: it's like a car dealer who tells you the sticker is just a ceiling, then charges sticker on four out of five cars. Technically true. Not a reason to walk in with your maximum on a sign around your neck.

In a true second-price auction, bidding your full value per click is roughly the right move, because the auction hands back the gap. In a first-price auction you shade, bidding below your value and accepting you'll lose some auctions. A lot of Amazon playbooks (and honestly, a lot of the bid rules sitting in agency tools) still assume the first world.

Your 2022 Black Friday CPC is a bad benchmark

The most common Q4 planning move I see is "take last year's or two years ago's Cyber Week CPC, add some inflation, set bids and budgets." If the complaint is even partly right, those historical CPCs include surcharge you can't separate out, and on peak days the alleged markup was largest exactly when everyone was pulling benchmarks.

Amazon's counter-data is worth weighing, to be fair. It says average Sponsored Products search CPC was flat after inflation from 2019 to 2024, and that winning bids fell 50%. Both things can sort of be true at once: average CPC flat across the year while peak days spike hard. That's kind of the point. Annual averages hide the days you actually care about in November.

So don't swap one absolute benchmark for another. Track a ratio instead.

The CPC-to-bid ratio audit (about 20 minutes)

Pull your Sponsored Products targeting report for the last 60 days and for last year's November 20 to December 2 window if you still have it. For each keyword or target with meaningful clicks:

  1. Divide average CPC by the effective bid. Effective bid means your base bid with placement adjustments applied, and with dynamic bidding taken into account. Under "up and down," Perpetua's bidding guide notes Amazon can raise bids up to 100% for top-of-search placements, so your "max" may not be the number in the bid column.
  2. Flag every target where the ratio is above 0.9. Those are the ones where you're effectively paying first-price.
  3. For flagged targets, recompute the bid from value: target ACoS × average order value × conversion rate. At a 25% target ACoS, a $40 AOV and a 12% conversion rate, that's $1.20 per click. If your current effective bid is $1.80 because "second price will save us," it probably won't.
  4. Log the ratio daily from November 20 through Cyber Monday (November 30). If it jumps on peak days while conversion rate stays flat, that's click cost moving, not shopper intent. Screenshot it. You'll want it for the client conversation and maybe for the lawyers.

A rough benchmark: the complaint's 2020 data suggests a mostly second-price auction charges your own bid on single-digit percentages of clicks. If most of your targets sit near 1.0, you should plan as though you're in the 2024 auction the FTC describes, not the one in the help docs.

Also keep one or two manual-bid campaigns running as a control, even if you've handed everything else to automation. Relevant Audience makes the same suggestion, and I think it's the cheapest insurance on this list.

Some old client conversations get reopened

Here's a slightly uncomfortable side effect. If you ran Amazon for clients in 2021 to 2023 and explained a holiday ROAS drop as "competition got heavier," you might want to revisit that with them, using the FTC's language rather than your own. Nobody enjoys that call. But it's better coming from you than from a client who reads the press release first.

This connects to a pattern we've covered a few times now. When we wrote about the original filing in September, the takeaway was that the platform runs the auction, grades the auction and reports the results. Amazon's upcoming change to how Store display impressions get counted is the same issue from another angle. Platform-reported numbers aren't audited by anyone you hired.

Where I think this lands

My guess, and it's only a guess: there's maybe a 60% chance Amazon adds some explicit reserve-price disclosure inside the ad console (a "charged at bid" share, or a reserve indicator per placement) before Prime Day 2027, settlement or not. Regulators now have internal emails tied to a $40 million gap, and the cheapest way to make that story go away is transparency it can control.

I could be wrong about the timing. Litigation moves slowly and Amazon clearly intends to fight. But for this Black Friday it doesn't really matter how the case ends. You can measure the ratio yourself, starting tonight, and bid as if the number you type is the number you'll pay. On the evidence so far, most of the time it is.

By Notice Me Senpai Editorial